Archive for: Presentations

This is an excerpt from a recent CGAP paper, The Early Experience with Branchless Banking. The paper synthesizes the observations and research of the CGAP Technology Program. Gautam Ivatury and Ignacio Mas wrote the paper, with substantial input from the entire program team. This blog series will cover seven observations, four uncertainties and four predictions for branchless banking - what we call mobile banking and other technology-enabled banking solutions.

Most financial service providers see partnerships with businesses that have a substantial local retail presence as a key competitive strategy. They act to build their networks as quickly as they can to expand the pool of potential customers and attain local brand presence. The pace of agent sign-up is most dramatic in Brazil, where 95,000 agents have opened for business, leaving no municipality without a retail bank outlet. This agent network has directly led to the opening of more than 13 million bank accounts in the past five years.

Depending on regulations, agents can be used to open new accounts (signing up customers and conducting customer due diligence) or to conduct customers’ cash transactions (to deposit into or withdraw from an account, or to make or receive payments). Given the finding that most branchless banking customers do not build sizable deposit balances (per observation 3, above), most customer transactions do in fact entail a cash transaction. Many banks that want to enter into branchless banking have partnered with businesses that have many local outlets so that they can jump-start their agent networks, including mobile operators, post offices, and major retail chains:

• Mobile operators. Mobile operators run some of the largest national retail distribution networks to support prepaid card sales. This puts them in a strong position to lead or participate in mobile banking projects. For instance, five banks have partnered with SMART Communications in the Philippines, and Standard Bank in South Africa partnered with mobile operator MTN in South Africa.

• Post offices. Brazil’s Banco Bradesco purchased the rights to use the national post office network as a banking agent network. Bradesco created the Banco Postal subsidiary to trade on the trust that Brazil’s population has in the postal service and to differentiate from Bradesco’s branding as one of the leading private banks in the country. By May 2007, Banco Postal had an agent network of about 5,600 agents, two-thirds of which were post offices. The rest were retail outlets branded as “Bradesco Expresso” points.

• Major retail chains. Equity Bank in Kenya signed a deal in mid-2007 to use the Nakumatt chain of retail stores as its anchor banking agents, and WIZZIT has arranged to use the Dunn’s chain of about 400 clothing stores across small town South Africa to act as account opening locations. Where banks are unable to partner with large retail chains, or in rural areas where these chains have limited or no presence, banks often outsource the building and management of chains of agents to third-party agent management companies. Banco Popular in Brazil (the banking correspondent brand of Banco do Brasil) uses companies such as Net Cash in Sao Paulo State and the Brasilia Federal District and Pag Facil in Pernambuco to sign up, equip, train, and maintain agents on its behalf. Lemon Bank has no branches at all and relies on 16 agent management companies (including three that it purchased) to manage the majority of its 5,750 agents.

A bank’s ability to sign up agents in disparate locations depends on the national payments system rules and practices. Referring back to the Brazilian success case, a second legal provision spurred geographic coverage to such a stunning extent: an agent is legally able to deposit its excess cash in to its account with its sponsoring bank through the branch of any bank, at no extra cost, and without having to open an account at that bank. The situation is quite different in Colombia, for instance, where the bank with the largest network of rural branches, state-owned Banco Agrario, charges such high cash handling fees to other banks that those banks cannot profitably set up agents in remote municipalities. While Banco Agrario’s high cash handling fees may be justified by the high cost of operating in such remote locations, the result is that other banks are not able to use agents unless they set up their own branches nearby.

Based on our observations, it appears that being an early mover in creating an agent network confers three key competitive advantages:

• Early movers are able to partner exclusively with the businesses that have the largest number of local retail outlets, thereby patching together a sizable agent network relatively quickly. Subsequent entrants are likely to find it more difficult to assemble an agent network of their own, particularly in areas with few retail establishments. The number of agents or physical locations is an easy concept to differentiate advertising, and hence it becomes a self-sustaining advantage for early movers.

• Early movers with larger agent network scan negotiate more favorable agreements with utility companies and various government agencies to distribute or collect payments on their behalf. As noted earlier, most banks realize that payments (from customers to utility companies and lenders, and from governments to welfare and pension beneficiaries) is the first product likely to move through this channel.

• A bank that is first to introduce banking services in a given geography is likely to capture greatest market share among the local population. The general manager of Banco Popular in Brazil explained that putting Banco Popular agents in unserved neighborhoods gave the bank a presence and the start of a relationship with local customers. As these communities develop and become increasingly banked, Banco Popular would be the bank whose name they would remember the best.

Mobile banking has gotten more than its fair share of adulatory press coverage this year. Most exciting perhaps was April’s Sunday New York Times magazine piece that looked at the broader opportunities of mobile phones and development through the lens of the work of Jan Chipchase of Nokia fame. Last week we saw the Financial Times consider the state of microfinance with a nod towards how mobile phones could reduce transaction costs and increase the reach of financial services.

This topic is only getting more interesting. Last week I had the opportunity to speak via videolink to a conference in Brazil on how the web could revolutionize - or is revolutionizing - life in developing countries - via cell phones. That was a great conversation, organized by our friends at the World Bank and linked up to the Workshop on the Role of Mobile Technologies in Fostering Social Development, organized by the people who brought you those three w’s in your web browser, W3C.

Read the rest of this page »

For some, El Salvador is famous for some of the best surf spots in Central America. For others it is the kilometer-long black-sanded beaches that come to mind. This week, for the Latin microfinance community, San Salvador will be famous for one of the largest and most reputable microfinance events of the region: The 10th Inter-American Forum on Microenterprise.

Looking at the agenda, the three day conference brings together an amazing group of around 1,500 of the region’s microfinance providers, its networks, governments, donors, and even the royals with the participation of H. M. Queen Sofia of Spain.

CGAP is organizing a panel on technology’s potential to increase outreach and depth of access to finance. Our project partners Visa Credibanco and GXI, as well as Opportunity International will share their lessons learned and challenges to implement technology projects.

Watch this space for more.

That was fun. What did we learn? 

We reaffirmed that small, including micro, enterprises have proven themselves to be reliable and sustainable ways to help people out of poverty and that, in that context, we have abundant proof that microfinance is a workable idea.

MFIs, although having reached increasingly impressive numbers of people, must nonetheless recognize that more than two-thirds of the inhabitants of developing countries remain to be touched by the MFI mission of bringing the advantages of banking to the unbanked and under-banked.

Read the rest of this page »

In her opening remarks, Elizabeth Littlefield used the example of Brazil to illustrate two points. Since the government began allowing use of banking agents to deliver financial services several years ago, 98% of the municipalities now have easy access to financial services. That number is enviable by all standards. At the same time, one network manager experienced an 85% turnover in agents during the first few years.

Read the rest of this page »

Happy Monday…this Monday is more auspicious than most because it’s the start of our three day conference looking at how technologies such as card-based networks and mobile phones could increase access to finance. IFC is a co-organizer, and Visa is a sponsor.

Want to know more? Visit here for the full agenda.

We’ll be posting presentations as we get them…and this link should take you to a live video stream of the event.

…this is how Brian Richardson, CEO of WIZZIT started off his presentation at a conference earlier this month in Cartagena, Colombia.

The two-day event brought together a great cast of experts including representatives from the Procredit network, GXI(Philippines), Banco Azteca (Mexico), the Colombian Superintendent of Banks, as well as David Porteous and Ernesto Aguirre (who also advise the CGAP Technology Program). This very diverse group of practitioners, regulators, and technology providers created a great base to discuss and share experiences and challenges on how to provide low-income clients in Latin America and other regions with access to financial services.  The presentations touched on a range of issues vital to successfully scaling up microfinance: market research, product development, financial education, innovative delivery channels, and supporting regulation.

Even though the use of technology and new business models to push the access frontier was a major theme of the conference, the constant theme throughout all the presentations was that technology and innovative delivery channels are only part of what it takes to scale up microfinance and reach people we cannot reach today.

BancoEstado from Chile presented impressive information about the clients they want to serve. They used this knowledge on customer perceptions and preferences to design an account product without monthly account fees, but “pay per use.”   In India, banks have been experimenting with ways to support microfinance and ICICI Bank presented its partnership model, disaggregating the microfinance value chain: Banks use microfinance institutions and NGOs as banking agents to handle savings and credit transactions.   The Central Bank of the Philippines explained how they started to adapt regulation to foster innovation, but at the same time protect consumers and the financial system.

All these delegates are true pioneers and still experimenting with the right operational approaches, organizational set-ups, regulatory frameworks, demand-driven products, and a lot of other issues to ensure client take up and increase access to finance in their market.

It will take time to unleash ready-made solutions that reach the very poor in remote areas on a viable basis, and it will require substantial commitment and investment from providers.

Want more presentations? Visit the Asobancaria website.

Stefan Staschen works with CGAP’s technology and policy teams. He presented on CGAP’s behalf at the Third African Microfinance Conference in Kampala late in August, and shared with us his impressions of the conference.

Not one or two or three, but four presentations at the AMC in Kampala, Uganda, dealt with the use of technology for increasing access to financial services. Richard Ketley from Genesis Analytics talked about Alternative Service Delivery Mechanisms and the card and phone revolution in Africa. His main conclusion was that African microfinance institutions (MFIs) can leverage existing technology such as mobile phones, ATMs and the internet to counter the negative impact of operating in a high cost environment and more often than not using inefficient business models.

Read the rest of this page »

Banking agents, retail and postal outlets handling banking transactions for financial institutions and mobile operators, are mushrooming all over! It took less than four years to cover almost all of Brazil. Colombian banks established 3,548 service points in just one year. In Peru banks manage more than 2,500 agents. Equity Bank in Kenya is piloting agents in rural areas. Xac Bank in Mongolia is planning to develop an agent channel….

Read the rest of this page »

We’re at a banking conference in Sao Paulo, where I had a chance to present on agents and our work in Colombia. In terms of using banking agents to reach remote areas and poor clients, the Brazilian financial system represents probably the future of many Latin American markets. Whereas countries like Colombia are just starting to develop such outlets, in Brazil they already make up 56% of all financial system points of sale are, reaching all municipalities.

Since our last visit in June 2006, the atmosphere has changed a lot. Whereas last year, banks were still experimenting with different approaches and were not yet convinced that banking agents were viable, today everybody we asked during our last week in Sao Paulo, considered banking agents a profitable channel. Banking agents move clients which are high cost for the bank (small ticket size, often only limited usage of products) to the low-cost agent channel, and free space in branches for clients which generate more revenue for the bank. Before branches were full of people just paying their bills. Read the rest of this page »