Mobile banking to transform microfinance
CGAP finds market conditions mean benefits for poor still several years away
A new report from the global microfinance body CGAP predicts that, with the right market conditions, mobile banking could reach large numbers of poor people who are outside the formal financial system. The Early Experience with Branchless Banking calls for the development of interoperable payments platforms, practical and risk-based approaches to regulation, as well as shared networks of cash-handling agents. There is also a need for product development that overcomes the lack of human interaction and reliability concerns that may hinder customer adoption today.
“Market forces are driving down costs. In the Philippines, we see that a transaction on a cell phone or at an ATM costs one fifth that of a traditional visit to a bank branch,” said Gautam Ivatury, manager of CGAP’s Technology Program and co-author of the report. “Yet globally, we estimate that fewer than one in ten mobile phone banking customers are poor, new to banking, or doing anything more than payments and transfers.”
Payments and funds transfers dominate mobile financial services for many reasons, the report finds. Mobile operators in particular prefer to market payments services as this is more aligned with traditional revenue models. These services are also less likely to cause operators to run afoul of banking regulation.
“When it comes to reaching poor people who live outside the formal financial sector, the reality of mobile phone banking doesn’t match the potential, much less the hype, at least not yet, said Ignacio Mas, CGAP advisor and co-author of the report. ”We see opportunities for service providers who move quickly to create new products, especially if they can establish shared networks of cash-handling agents to cover that ‘last mile’ of service delivery.”
The report finds that challenges to the growth of branchless banking include a reluctance on the part of banks to get involved, as well as outdated or inadequate regulations. This is true despite the benefits of branchless banking: convenience, better security, and lower costs for customers. In cases where market conditions are not driving broader banking services such as credit and savings, there may be a role to play for policymakers and those who advocate for increased financial access.
The Early Experience with Branchless Banking will be presented at the GSMA Mobile Money Summit in Cairo on May 14.
