Archive for: Implementation

Mobile operators have notched some high profile successes in offering financial services to the poor. Think M-PESA in Kenya or GCash and Smart Money in the Philippines. They’ve have logged several million users for their mobile money transfer services which appear cheaper and more convenient than traditional banking products.

Will banks respond by emulating their new competitors from the mobile world? Banks have an appetite for offering multiple products to their clients, so it would be a boon to the poor if banks wanted to ramp up their offerings via new electronic channels. But the emerging picture is not always rosy.

Many banks see mobile as merely a threat, according to IFC’s Andi Dervishi, who leads investments in alternative-payments systems for the IFC. “Banks remain conservative. They don’t see this as a big opportunity. They are taking a more defensive position, rather than offensive, and not really going after the customer. Their business model needs to be changed.” Countries like India, China, Brazil and Russia now have more mobile phones than ATMs, giving rise to the notion that mobile will support the next wave of innovation in banking in emerging markets where low-revenue customers means banks need to find low-cost channels. But instead of jumping to explore, most banks are playing defense.

Read the rest of this page »

This is an excerpt from a recent CGAP paper, The Early Experience with Branchless Banking. The paper synthesizes the observations and research of the CGAP Technology Program. Gautam Ivatury and Ignacio Mas wrote the paper, with substantial input from the entire program team. This blog series will cover seven observations, four uncertainties and four predictions for branchless banking - what we call mobile banking and other technology-enabled banking solutions.

Early movers with a disruptive business model can afford to be picky about the segments they address. Emboldened by a dramatic cost advantage over established players, they are able to focus on the most attractive customer segments. As long as these constitute a sufficiently large pool of people to meet their growth aspirations, they have little incentive to expand into others. They will concentrate on building defensive barriers through scale (growing quickly) and depth of retail network, rather than on expanding into new segments and service offerings. Thus it is, as explained above, that early branchless banking projects have not addressed the currently unserved population.

However, the benefits of the cost advantage will be eroded overtime as their own success induces new entrants or the adaptation of existing players to the new cost structure. With greater competition, the focus of new entrants will be on expanding the market so as to avoid head-to-head competition for market share with early movers who will have secured a strong position through scale. Hence, we can expect targeting of currently unserved customers to come not with the innovation but with the competition phase of branchless banking.

One should not underestimate the market-transforming potential of solutions that cut the cost of service provision at least 50 percent or so. What is less clear is how long it will take for the competitive dynamics to play out for the benefit of currently underserved populations.

They both re-engineer something used for decades in rich countries , rethinking every assumption to make it affordable for low-income clients. And both may be safer than the alternatives poor people are already using.

Tata announced the Nano last week as an ultra simple but stylish car costing US$2500, closer to affordable for Indian families than any other new car. To slash prices, Tata engineers questioned everything conventional wisdom said is a “must have”: why not one large windshield wiper instead of two? Why does the beam connecting the wheel to the axle need to be made of solid steel? Today’s steel is far stronger than what Henry Ford started with, but no one had changed it yet. Less steel equals saved expense, and a lower cost in the quest for something rabidly cost-conscious consumers will buy in emerging markets like India.

But critics are bashing the Nano already for not getting close to meeting environmental and car safety standards like those in Europe, Japan and North America. Isn’t the Nano safer than the typical sight of an Indian family of 6 on one motorcycle, dodging trucks in traffic?

The lesson might be instructive for those watching the mobile banking space. Would mobile banking, through a licensed bank or reputable mobile carrier, be safer than the informal mechanisms poor people use now: stuffing cash in the mattress? or saving through poorly regulated cooperatives? sending money through bus drivers and friends, who might not deliver it at all? Research is needed to know. Read the rest of this page »

Right after the government in 2005 had enabled banks to use banking agents, retail and postal outlets to handle transactions on behalf of banks, a number of Peruvian banks started to roll out their agent networks. One of them, Banco de Credito (BCP) with their “agentes BCP.”

Already in November 2006, Mr. Luis Almandoz, BCP’s man in charge of their agents, had presented the bank’s thorough planning of the network roll out at a conference in Colombia. Last week, newspaper El Comercio, described the bank’s success story installing more than 1,000 banking agents with lightening speed (1.5 agents per day!). Rather than the expected 300,000 transactions, the agents process today 900,000 transactions per month (i.e., around 30 transactions per day per agent).

The planning phase paid off and the bank’s learning curve was steep: “At the beginning it took us 3 days to open a new banking agent, today we need maximum 4 hours. Once we have one agent in a neighborhood, within three months, there will be three more.” said Almandoz.

The new channel, for which BCP won the 2006 Business Creativity Award (Premio Creatividad Empresarial), benefited all actors involved:

• Clients can now transact closer to their home at agents not only in urban Lima, but also in some parts of rural Peru. Almandoz also mentions reduced transaction cost: “mine workers often pay up to S/.30 (US$10) to transact in non-bank establishments.” Whereas bill payments at the BCP agents are free of charge, and account fees are low.
• Seventy percent of the agents were able to increase their sales by around 12% due to the increased foot traffic generated from their work for BCP. In addition, they earn around US$45 – US$200 per month in commissions.
• BCP was able to increase their coverage by 1,000 points and process transactions for over S/. 1m (US$ 330,000) at each agent each month.

The question is what are BCP’s secrets of success….. one is definitely their marketing (the bank’s anual marketing budget is around US$300-450k) and definitely their commitment and thorough planning. But how are they managing cash? We hope to find out….

Other banks like Interbank, Scotiabank, and Mibanco are also gearing up in Peru and the network of agents is expected to increase massively next year.

An important part of effectively rolling out a banking agent network - a network of retail or postal outlets that handles transactions on behalf of financial institutions and mobile operators - is the agent location. 

Our project partner, Credibanco VISA in Colombia, is using a georeferencing tool to advise banks as to where large numbers of their target clients are located, and also which retail outlets in that area might make good “corresponsales no bancarios”, as the Colombians call their banking agents.

The process is easy. Based on the bank’s target clientele (e.g., income up to COP 250,000 per month [US$122] and “estrato 2″ reflecting the Colombian economic classification of 0-6, where 0 is poorest and 6 highest income) and preferred location (e.g. high population density, no financial infrastructure, etc.), VISA uses census data, financial infrastructure coverage, and retail information from yellow pages to develop heatmaps which combine the following:

• poverty and income levels 
• population density
• postcode boundaries
• existing financial infrastructure (e.g. branches, ATMs, etc.) and card holders
• stores and other commercial activity
• areas that generate a lot of foot traffic (e.g. bus stations, markets, hospitals, etc.)

Based on the resulting maps, the bank can see in which areas their agent would be most effective. Factors like poverty and income level, population density, and existing financial infrastructure will impact the agent’s future transaction volume; placing agents near bus stops and market areas will make them more visible and increase the likelihood that clients will repeatedly use the agent to conduct transactions.

On the picture you see the final heatmap. Red areas show neighborhoods with great opportunity to reach the bank’s target clients; the mountains refer to population density. If you would like more detail, please send me an email and I can forward you VISA’s complete analysis of Ciudad Bolivar, a poor neighborhood of Bogota, Colombia.

What do you do when your client is nomadic, lives in an area with no electricity, roads, or GSM coverage, but plenty of bandits?

Two CGAP partners are devising solutions to just such a situation in Kenya. Vodafone and a consortium of PayNet, Kenya Commercial Bank and Sevak Solutions are awardees from the Social Protection Payments Challenge Fund, co-financed by CGAP and FSD Kenya.  The two awardees are developing prototypes to deliver social protection payments to families with orphans and food insecure households in the arid north bordering Somalia, Ethiopia, and Sudan. Both have chosen approaches that rely on technology to drop the cost of delivering the grants, while giving beneficiaries and others access to other financial services.

But northern Kenya is a tough environment to do banking. In an area the same size as the UK, there are 3 bank branches. In one district, Kwale, a family of five typically gets by on 300 Kenyan Shillings per day, or under USD 5. Garissa district houses a major refugee camp for Somalis. About the busiest place is Loki, with 100 flights daily for UN and other agencies staging relief aid into Southern Sudan. Why so many flights? Because police have declared the road impossible to protect from bandits, starting 600 km to the south.

Read the rest of this page »

Banking agents, retail and postal outlets handling banking transactions for financial institutions and mobile operators, are mushrooming all over! It took less than four years to cover almost all of Brazil. Colombian banks established 3,548 service points in just one year. In Peru banks manage more than 2,500 agents. Equity Bank in Kenya is piloting agents in rural areas. Xac Bank in Mongolia is planning to develop an agent channel….

Read the rest of this page »

Putting in place a cost-effective, efficient, scalable core banking system (or information system) is a tough job for any business. For many small and medium microfinance institutions (MFIs), it’s proven to be virtually impossible. Strong IT staff are hard to come by and retain, managers have limited training in making IT decisions, and getting loan officers and accountants to buy into a new system is no piece of cake.

When are these MFIs going to learn to stick to their knitting and outsource their IT systems, just like the rest of the financial services world? … Well, maybe it’s not so easy…

Read the rest of this page »