Archive for: Customer Value

For the last year CGAP has conducted quantitative research on the challenge of inactive customers. In culmination of this research, we are releasing a deck that helps providers understand and develop strategies to address low customer activity in their services.

Regular readers of this blog are familiar with the challenge of low customer activity and the negative impact this has on the business case. Last year, CGAP released a framework to map how a potential customer moves from awareness to ongoing activity and all the different dimensions of a business required to make this successful. As we worked with providers to understand this problem, it became clear that one of the first steps was to help providers analyze the gold mine of information they already have about their own customers. Understanding customers is a complex undertaking and will ultimately rely on a variety of tools such as focus groups and surveys. Yet the starting point should be a data-driven understanding of current customer trends and segments which then highlights areas to research further.

We worked with four providers in three regions to analyze customer registration, customer transaction and agent registration datasets. We conducted many different types of analysis – general activity trends, money transfer patterns and regression analyses to determine which factors are most correlated with high customer activity. The analysis revealed the untapped well of customer insights that providers have but most are not using.

This deck summarizes some of the most interesting findings on data analysis and customer activity across the providers. There are no magic bullets in the deck and, in fact, we found that data from providers in different markets was in some cases contradictory, highlighting that insights from one market are not automatically transferable to other markets. The deck does identify which types of data providers should be collecting, what types of analysis we found to be most useful in understanding activity levels and how providers can act on the data analysis with adjustments in service offerings or follow-on qualitative research.

Many results were consistent across multiple geographies and types of services. Some highlights:

• Super Users – Each service has a small but very loyal and highly active group of “super users” responsible for a higher proportion of total transactions. 5% of users were responsible for 30% of the total value transacted.
• Super Agents – The activity rate of customers registered by the best agents is over 40 times higher than those registered by the worst agents.
• Local transfers – About half (48%) of all transfers happen locally within the same province, indicating that P2P transfer patterns do not always follow the long-distance “send money home” pattern that we’ve seen in M-PESA Kenya.
• Demographics – Customer demographics have a significant impact on activity levels. Female customers are 41% more likely to be active than males. At one provider, activity rates for some occupation segments like students and farmers is three times the overall activity rate for the service.

Each of these items is a tantalizing nugget that suggests data-driven, actionable follow-on strategies that can be created to impact customer activity levels. In the next few weeks we will be writing about some of the most interesting findings in more detail. For now, check out the deck and consider how you or providers you work with can make better use of the data at hand to start tackling low customer activity.

- Claudia McKay & Toru Mino

Read our first post in this series on branchless banking in India here.

Anand Shrivastav, the founder of the mobile phone prepaid system Beam, says simply that his start up offers “convenience, not a financial service.” While sitting in his office, I opened up a prepaid account with Beam in less than a minute with a one line SMS message.

This simplicity is not what the government of India has in mind when it promotes financial inclusion. The Reserve Bank of India articulates the end goal of financial inclusion to be a full set of deposit, savings, insurance and payment services offered with bank-like rigor. The RBI has promoted bank-led branchless banking to achieve this agenda with considerable expansion occurring under the bank-led model across India. By March 2012 there should be close to 100,000 customer service points (also called bank agents) across India.

Beam is one example, however, of a mobile phone based service that offers something much simpler and lies at the far end of the spectrum of financial services. Beam is licensed by the RBI, but instead of a banking license Beam operates with a license to offer prepaid payment services. This license allows Beam to issue prepaid value electronically; presently with the (very significant) restriction that such value cannot be redeemed for cash, only for goods or services. Prepaid licenses specifically prevent Beam’s service from mimicking a deposit.

The first thing that strikes a new user like me is the ease of signing up. I did this without visiting any office or even presenting identification. Mr. Shrivastav explains that the initial account opening is geared to be ultra-convenient and is not intended to meet banking identification (Know Your Customer – KYC) rigor. Stricter bank level identification is intended to combat money laundering and terrorist financing which one cannot do (or would find extremely difficult to do) using prepaid value restricted to goods or services. Mr. Shrivastav explains that Beam has introduced a higher tier account where users voluntarily upgrade their account by submitting KYC details, allowing them to transact in larger amounts. But the ease of initial account opening has enabled a small start up company like Beam to open up 7 million accounts.

Read the rest of this page »

“Cash is easy.” “Cash is what I know most.” “There are no charges when I use cash.”

Ghana Market Seller (Photo Taken by Adam Jones)

I was sitting in a little room in the outskirts of Accra listening to a group of tomato sellers talk about the financial tools they use to manage their finances. As a part of CGAP’s work in Ghana, we have commissioned Bankable Frontiers Associates (working with Easy Errands, a Ghanaian market research firm) to conduct a market research study on the financial needs of low-income customers in Ghana. One of the first steps was to conduct focus groups throughout the country and listen to diverse groups of Ghanaians, including farmers, taxi drivers, traders and students, talk about their strategies for moving and storing money. They discussed bank transfers and drivers and the use of family and friends but more than anything, they talked about cash.

The trite expression ‘Cash is King’ is over-used in our line of work, but as I sat in that little room listening to these people whom mobile money services have spent millions of dollars trying to woo, I realized yet again that the biggest competition we face in scaling branchless banking is not a rival MNO or bank or even the expensive money transfer operators – it’s cash. (Read some recent posts on our blog about this topic here and here.)

Cash is far and away the preferred method for storing and sending money in Ghana, no matter how inconvenient. One tomato seller, Charity, wraps her cash in no less than six black plastic bags and hides it in the back of her refrigerator, underneath her tomatoes and meats, so that the rest of her family does not suspect it is there.  A timber seller, Emmanuel, told us he keeps his cash under the carpet in his living room. When asked whether the cash does not form a noticeable bulk, he replied with a big grin, ‘That’s why I spread it all around so that people walk all over my cash but have no idea it is beneath their feet!’

Read the rest of this page »

I think it is safe to say that the financial inclusion world has started to get used to the idea of thinking about financial service providers more broadly than traditional microfinance institutions, rural banks and financial cooperatives. With the recent growth of mobile network operators, technology providers and agent network managers, it’s evident that financial inclusion encompasses a broad set of providers. But even I am sometimes surprised to learn about some private companies that seem to have a very tangential link to the unbanked financial sector taking advantage of new opportunities in branchless banking.

Take OXXO as an example. OXXO is the largest convenience store in Mexico (comparable to 7-Eleven in the US) opening a new store every 8 hours…yes that’s 8 hours!  7.5 million people come through their stores every day, most of whom are looking for things that a normal convenience store would offer…food, snacks, paper goods, etc. But OXXO is diversifying its products to offer its wide customer base the “convenience for everything you’d need in life any time of day.”

In this video, Aiko Fujimura, Manager of Financial Services for OXXO, explains how this added convenience extends now to financial services offered through the OXXO e-wallet. She admits that there are certain challenges. “It is easy to sell soda and snacks, but not as easy to sell financial services.” Training a huge network of employees and convincing people to trust the store with their money are two issues OXXO is currently facing.

Few companies have the scale of OXXO, but convenience stores and other retail outlets are still being used to build up branchless banking agent networks. In this video, Johannes Kling of the agent network company DD-DEDO talks about the role that convenience stores play in Colombia in expanding the outreach of banks. As he explains, Colombia is still very early on in the growth curve when it comes to branchless banking. But as we all know, a strong agent network is one of the early pieces of the puzzle in building a branchless banking ecosystem.

Next week, we’ll share two more videos from more traditional players – a bank and a mobile network operator – but each with an interesting take on their new business model to reach the unbanked.

- Sarah Rotman

Today we post a guest blog by Ignacio Mas and David Porteous, both of whom need no introduction. But just in case…Ignacio is an independent consultant, associated with Bankable Frontier Associates. He is former Senior Advisor with the Financial Services for the Poor team at the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and at the Technology and Business Model Innovation Program at CGAP. David is Managing Director of Bankable Frontier Associates.

Sarah Rotman blogged recently about yet another breathless announcement about the imminent arrival of the cashless society. She said and we agree that “cashless seems a bit naïve; cash lite seems more realistic although still a big challenge.” The very first part of the challenge is actually to visualize what a “cash lite” world looks like. Is it simply an ill-defined way station on the road to cashlessness, or is there a meaningful state or goal that goes with it?

We think the latter, and for us the defining characteristic is not the amount of cash (let cash do what it will!), but the availability of alternatives for the bulk of the population. It’s freedom from cash, not absence of cash. We have coined a word which encapsulates key elements of a cash lite society: LiFi (see baptismal paper here). Like WiFi, which provides retail connectivity at the edge of the internet cloud, LiFi is about connecting people to an electronic payments grid which provides Liquidity with Fidelity. WiFi is open, general-purpose broadband; LiFi is secure, special-purpose narrowband.

A LiFi world is therefore one in which every person has an electronic store of value which they can easily use to make and receive payments in real time. Just like in places with reliable on-grid electricity, we can turn on a light on-demand, knowing that it will work and that the cost of flicking the switch will be small in relation to the benefits.

Because there is no precedent for cashlessness by fiat and cash can be counted on to still be an option for a long time to come, the key challenge of LiFi is getting people to trust and want to use the LiFi payment mechanism…because it is robust, because it is safe and because it is useful. All these attributes take time to demonstrate to the satisfaction of risk- (and change-) averse users. A LiFi approach recognizes that in two ways.

Read the rest of this page »

This is a guest post by Peter Goldstein and Caldwell Bishop of InterMedia. Peter is Director of Communications for InterMedia and Project Director of AudienceScapes, an African research program and online knowledge center for the global development field funded by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. Caldwell is a communications intern at InterMedia and is currently pursuing a Masters in International Development at George Washington University. 

We all remember the devastating 7.0 earthquake that struck Haiti in January 2010 reportedly destroying about one-third of the country’s bricks-and-mortar bank branches, limiting Haitians’ ability to send and receive money transfers, cash checks, or simply access much-needed cash resources.

In June 2010, the Financial Services for the Poor initiative at the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation partnered with USAID on the Haiti Mobile Money Initiative (HMMI), featuring a $10 million fund to provide incentives to mobile service providers to quickly launch and expand m-money services. Notably, Digicel, Haiti’s leading mobile provider, won the first-to-market prize of $2.5 million in January 2011 after launching its Tcho Tcho Mobile service. Soon thereafter, Voila, Haiti’s second largest mobile provider, released its T-Cash m-money service and received a $1.5 million USD second-to-market award. The CGAP Technology Blog has had several posts on this initiative (here, here, here, here, and here).

To help monitor the impact of the HMMI as well as m-money service use and financial access in general, the Gates Foundation commissioned InterMedia to design and conduct a series of household surveys of Haitian adults (aged 18+).  The first  Haiti Mobile Money Tracker (HMMT) survey was conducted in March 2011, in the early days of m-money usage, and sampled all ten Haitian administrative departments based on figures from the latest census in 2003. Follow-up surveys will be conducted to establish usage trends – hopefully based on a more up-to-date 2011 census.

InterMedia’s HMMT Online Data Analysis Tool allows financial access practitioners and stakeholders to dive into the survey data themselves in a user-friendly way. The combinations of financial, mobile and demographic data are easily cross-referenced to support project planning and analysis.

Meanwhile, the first survey yielded some helpful insights and provided rare baseline data for a mobile money deployment. Here are some of the highlights:

Read the rest of this page »

Everyone is always talking about trying to move the branchless banking industry beyond just payments. Those of us concerned with accelerating “real financial inclusion” long to see credit, savings and insurance products pushed over new delivery channels. But is it possible that there’s still work to be done within the payments space itself, just diversifying a bit beyond simple P2P transfers?

For example, I’ve been hearing a lot of talk recently about really trying to crack the nut on merchant payments. Branchless banking providers see this as a huge opportunity not only for increased transactions (and therefore revenue), but also as a way to solve some of the tricky problems around liquidity management at agent locations when more people use electronic value for direct purchases instead of just cashing in and out. But how do small merchants respond to the possibility of being brought into the formal economy through using a traceable payments service? Will merchants and customers be willing to pay a fee to transact electronically instead of in cash? These are just a couple of the open questions that still need to be answered.

I ran across the organization Venture Capital for Africa (VC4A) at a recent conference in Ethiopia. One of their recently profiled ventures is addressing some of these questions around moving past person-to-person transfers to merchant payments and other business transactions. The start-up Yo! Payments in Uganda is trying to connect the ecosystem and facilitate mobile money as a real “medium of exchange.” Read about some other pretty cool startups in the African mobile market here.

What about even fancier transactions than just merchant payments, like investments? At a recent African bonds market workshop in Nairobi, discussions involved the possibility of allowing mobile phone users to buy Treasury bonds through mobile money transfers. I wouldn’t bank your investments on this yet though, as the article was clear that “details are yet to be worked out” and this seems to be the sort of transaction where the devil is indeed in the details.

Read the rest of this page »

This is the fourth post in a series about product innovation in branchless banking. In the last post we threw the focus on direct observation of consumers to source deep insights that lead to better products. We also released our detailed analysis. Today’s post describes a second key feature of the three Product Labs which will be established by CGAP’s bank, telco and other partners.

Let’s say you are a manager who has bought into developing products beyond the standard liquid wallet and P2P functionality ubiquitous in branchless banking. You want to innovate. But the procedures, biases, and requirements of your own company are holding you back.

If you are not careful, your good ideas will die a slow death of endless internal analysis or be outright rejected because “the data’s just not there”. As one manager told us about his company, “This place is run by accountants. If you don’t have the data, you go nowhere.” How can you meet existing business needs, and also move forward rapidly to approval?

This is the question confronting senior managers CGAP interviewed at more than a dozen firms that ranged from a success story in mobile money in East Africa to the largest bank in a major Latin American market, the world’s largest handset manufacturer, and a leading South African supermarket chain adding financial services to boost customer loyalty.

This isn’t just a problem for senior managers. It is also a challenge in our Product Labs initiative. Each Lab will be implanted in a bank, telco, or other firm capable of massively scaling newly designed products via branchless banking channels. Labs will need to work with the ways that firms already design products. But the Labs could also help firms improve on two counts.

Picking the best ideas to pursue. All the firms interviewed said they rarely suffered for a lack of ideas. But they do suffer from the inability to tell which are worth chasing. As a result, choices are made haphazardly or, sometimes, all ideas are pursued with equal vigor. Managers felt stretched in too many directions and concepts that time showed to be worthwhile often took longer to emerge for want of enough resources.  Nearly all our interviewees agreed that earlier testing of ideas would help. But in many firms access to transactional platforms and core banking systems was tightly guarded. Pilots were something you do later in the product development process, not earlier.

Read the rest of this page »

This is the third post in a five-part series about product innovation in branchless banking. Read the first and second posts. This post includes a detailed presentation of CGAP’s analysis of 23 firms from banking, microfinance, mobile, fast moving consumer goods, and Silicon Valley. It also describes the key features of three Product Labs which will be established by CGAP’s bank, telco and other partners.

Some managers just aren’t interested in innovation. They see being on the leading edge as being on the bleeding edge. “Let someone else fail and then I’ll copy the successes.” Quite reasonable, if you can afford to be second.

For those who cannot, where can they turn for help crafting breakthrough products and services? Standard market research tools and data mining often fail to deliver the kind of unique insights needed to identify new growth opportunities. Several new approaches are in pilot in the microfinance field: randomized controlled trials, financial diaries, behavioral economics. These have already expanded our foundational knowledge about the financial lives of the poor. But they’ll need adaptation to fit the rapid timeframes preferred by the private sector.

To find better tools we looked at 5 industries that overlap with branchless banking: either they sell financial services (traditional banking, the microfinance sector), have low-income consumers as a target segment (microfinance, fast moving consumer goods), or use electronic channels (the mobile industry, Silicon Valley). We looked at 23 firms in total. The powerpoint here includes further details.

The common connection across most success stories was observing consumers rather than asking them. In interviews or focus group discussions consumers aren’t always honest, don’t remember accurately, may believe one thing but actually do otherwise, or may simply be of several minds about a topic but only tell you one facet of their viewpoint. Observing their lives and behavior allows us to pierce the fog cloaking unstated opinions and deeply-felt needs. That’s the space where breakthrough products evolve from. We’ll give an example:

Read the rest of this page »

Reaching the poor with a range of useful, convenient, and affordable financial services is challenging for all the reasons we know. In the context of Mexico, access has increased significantly in the past few years (nearly 60% of all households), and changes in regulation enabling correspondent banking are likely to bring the access barrier down even further. However, the challenge of delivering a relevant offering, tailored to the needs of the lower-income population still remains. This may be one of the reasons why many people who have access to formal financial services are not using them.

While consumer goods companies have developed an understanding of these segments, few actors in the financial services space have a deep knowledge of how “bottom of the pyramid” (BoP) customers use money and financial products, and what sort of products these customers may want in the future.

We conducted a study (available in both English and Spanish) in collaboration with McKinsey and Company, seeking to provide a closer look at the financial habits, needs, and wants of low-income customers in Mexico. The goal is to provide the kind of information that will enable financial service providers to design better products (i.e. products that reach more people and solve felt needs) and to implement products and business models with a greater chance of success.

We hope this study will help orient assumptions about customer behavior that can lead to improved product design and less risk in business models. Even though the study is intended to serve the Mexican market, we intend it to be useful and applicable to other markets.

Here are the key findings:

• Segments at the BoP save significantly. Deposits (both short term and long term) represent an amount equivalent to 20.4% of these segments’ annual aggregate income. If these deposits were to be held in formal financial institutions, the current deposit base in the formal financial sector would increase by 23.4%. Read the rest of this page »