Sarah Rotman works on the project and research agenda of the Technology Program, designing projects in the area of branchless banking in order to deliver financial services to unbanked customers. Her research projects include linking government payments to financial inclusion and exploring the business case for agents. Prior to joining CGAP, she was a Peace Corps volunteer in Benin, worked for a development nonprofit on educational projects in Haiti and Africa, and interned with an MFI in Rwanda. She has a master’s degree in international relations from Johns Hopkins SAIS.
We’ve done a lot of thinking at CGAP about the different business models and partnerships that exist in branchless banking. What I find interesting is that rarely do you find two models that look exactly alike. Once you begin to really dig beneath the surface, you realize that even among those businesses that we might simplistically call “telco-led” or “bank-led”, there are significant differences. For example, Orange’s partnership with BNP Paribas in Cote d’Ivoire (the local subsidiary BICICI) is slightly different than MTN’s partnership with Societe Generale (local subsidiary SGBCI) also in Cote d’Ivoire. Similarly, when we did our comparative agent research in Kenya, Brazil and India, we learned that while many banks in Brazil use agents extensively in their outreach strategy, they each manage their agent networks quite differently.
Instead of playing to the same tune, I’d say that branchless banking actors are playing variations on a theme. Here we share a couple videos that describe two particular variations out of the many that exist.
1st Variation: One of the largest Brazilian commercial banks Bradesco has been targeting the mass market since its beginning, going so far as to build branches without doors to encourage anyone to enter. It’s no surprise then that Bradesco has always been trying to be as close as possible to its customers (which currently number 62 million) and to future customers. In this video, Marcos Bader, General Director at Bradesco, explains how technology and new business models based on the use of agent networks have helped the bank reach this goal. He explains many interesting aspects of their business, but what I find quite remarkable in particular is that 90% of all transactions at the bank go through alternative distribution channels. Marcos also lives up to the Brazilian stereotype by somehow finding a way to draw a parallel between branchless banking and soccer!
2nd Variation: Regulation usually defines what branchless banking players can and cannot do. Roar Bjaerum, Head of easypaisa at Telenor Pakistan explains in this video how the regulation in Pakistan was clear in its “bank-led” approach. But regulation also allowed telcos to take ownership in banks. In 2008, this is exactly what Telenor Pakistan did in partnership with Tameer Microfinance Bank, paving the way for a truly innovative business model in branchless banking. As Roar explains, the market has since taken off in many different directions, with some banks leading their own branchless banking business and some telcos acquiring microfinance licenses. We’ve written about and discussed the Pakistan market a lot, but here Roar describes the market from the perspective of someone working on the day to day business of mobile money.
In these two particular “variations on a business model theme” and in the many others that exist around the world, the challenge, as Marcos puts it, is “to define the boundary between cooperation and competition.” This is indeed the task at hand in order to produce a wonderful melody instead of discordant chords in our objective to reach the unbanked.
Watch the two videos we posted last week on OXXO and DD-DEDO here.
I think it is safe to say that the financial inclusion world has started to get used to the idea of thinking about financial service providers more broadly than traditional microfinance institutions, rural banks and financial cooperatives. With the recent growth of mobile network operators, technology providers and agent network managers, it’s evident that financial inclusion encompasses a broad set of providers. But even I am sometimes surprised to learn about some private companies that seem to have a very tangential link to the unbanked financial sector taking advantage of new opportunities in branchless banking.
Take OXXO as an example. OXXO is the largest convenience store in Mexico (comparable to 7-Eleven in the US) opening a new store every 8 hours…yes that’s 8 hours! 7.5 million people come through their stores every day, most of whom are looking for things that a normal convenience store would offer…food, snacks, paper goods, etc. But OXXO is diversifying its products to offer its wide customer base the “convenience for everything you’d need in life any time of day.”
In this video, Aiko Fujimura, Manager of Financial Services for OXXO, explains how this added convenience extends now to financial services offered through the OXXO e-wallet. She admits that there are certain challenges. “It is easy to sell soda and snacks, but not as easy to sell financial services.” Training a huge network of employees and convincing people to trust the store with their money are two issues OXXO is currently facing.
Few companies have the scale of OXXO, but convenience stores and other retail outlets are still being used to build up branchless banking agent networks. In this video, Johannes Kling of the agent network company DD-DEDO talks about the role that convenience stores play in Colombia in expanding the outreach of banks. As he explains, Colombia is still very early on in the growth curve when it comes to branchless banking. But as we all know, a strong agent network is one of the early pieces of the puzzle in building a branchless banking ecosystem.
Next week, we’ll share two more videos from more traditional players – a bank and a mobile network operator – but each with an interesting take on their new business model to reach the unbanked.
One of the exciting and yet challenging aspects of the branchless banking industry is how fast things change. Topics discussed just 3 months ago can seem out of date today. That’s why it’s fun to look back over the topics we blogged about in 2011 starting from last January to see how the discussion has evolved over the last 12 months. Here are just a few of the blogs you may have missed or you may be interested in reading again:
In addition to these blogs, over the past year we released Branchless Banking Country Notes on 7 markets around the world, as well as an Agent Management Toolkit and a Branchless Banking Database. So just in case you returned to the office after a nice holiday break with nothing to do or read, we’ve got you covered! Happy New Year!
PayPal made news recently by launching a new report, Money: The Digital Tipping Point, which predicts that by 2016 UK consumers won’t need cash or a wallet to go shopping. I’m not sure why the UK market was the focus of this report, but I won’t tell PayPal that KPMG just came out with its own research that showed that “when it comes to mobile banking, consumers in the UK are more resistant than elsewhere. Only 27% of Brits surveyed said they had used some form of mobile banking in the past six months (globally 52%).”
But Carl Scheible, Managing Director of PayPal UK, is persistent and argues,
We’ll see a huge change over the next few years in the way we shop and pay for things. By 2016, you’ll be able to leave your wallet at home and use your mobile as the 21st century digital wallet.
I’ve been intrigued to see several recent new stories spouting off about the grandiose vision of a cashless society. To a certain extent I thought we had moved past this debate. While recognizing it as desirable, this high and mighty goal seems somewhat unattainable, at least in the short to medium term. At CGAP, a former colleague and I wrote about mostly failed attempts to go cashless in developed economies in the late 1990s and early 2000s through various mobile and electronic payment schemes. A few of us also wrote about the attempt in Singapore to dictate a cashless economy about 10 years ago, but to my knowledge I believe there’s still cash floating around Singapore.
Cashless seems a bit naive; cash lite seems more realistic, although still a big challenge despite the innovations that have happened since these initial attempts a decade ago.
A few weeks ago in Washington, DC, we hosted many of our partners who are implementing branchless banking products and services around the world. This was a chance not only for us to learn about the state of play of the industry at a global level, but also to allow the partners themselves to share learnings and experiences with each other.
Is there something that a nonbank electronic money issuer in Burkina Faso can learn from a state-owned commercial bank in India? Is there cross-learning between a mobile network operator in Pakistan and a large retail chain in Mexico? We think so. Chances are these businesses have more in common than we might think at first glance, especially if their overall objective is to reach the unbanked through innovative uses of technologies and new business models.
One of the topics we discussed together was the keys to building powerful partnerships. No one can launch a branchless banking service alone. Either an MNO must partner with a bank to hold the float, or an agent network company must partner with an MNO to provide the transaction channel, or a bank must partner with an MNO to build an agent network, or… the list could go on and on. If one thing is crystal clear in branchless banking, it is that partnerships are critical and yet partnerships are difficult.
So we asked our partners to brainstorm together and give us their top 10 list of recommendations for building powerful partnerships based on their experiences that we could share with the global industry (that’s you!). Here’s what they came up with, organized in three loose categories:
Broad strategy and vision:
1. Ensure that there is a long-term strategic alignment among partners with a shared common vision.
2. Align specific incentives and expectations on financial returns among partners.
3. Focus not only on commitment from top management but from the entire staff of an organization.
4. Do not ignore the soft factors like cultural fit among partners.
Everyone is always talking about trying to move the branchless banking industry beyond just payments. Those of us concerned with accelerating “real financial inclusion” long to see credit, savings and insurance products pushed over new delivery channels. But is it possible that there’s still work to be done within the payments space itself, just diversifying a bit beyond simple P2P transfers?
For example, I’ve been hearing a lot of talk recently about really trying to crack the nut on merchant payments. Branchless banking providers see this as a huge opportunity not only for increased transactions (and therefore revenue), but also as a way to solve some of the tricky problems around liquidity management at agent locations when more people use electronic value for direct purchases instead of just cashing in and out. But how do small merchants respond to the possibility of being brought into the formal economy through using a traceable payments service? Will merchants and customers be willing to pay a fee to transact electronically instead of in cash? These are just a couple of the open questions that still need to be answered.
I ran across the organization Venture Capital for Africa (VC4A) at a recent conference in Ethiopia. One of their recently profiled ventures is addressing some of these questions around moving past person-to-person transfers to merchant payments and other business transactions. The start-up Yo! Payments in Uganda is trying to connect the ecosystem and facilitate mobile money as a real “medium of exchange.” Read about some other pretty cool startups in the African mobile market here.
What about even fancier transactions than just merchant payments, like investments? At a recent African bonds market workshop in Nairobi, discussions involved the possibility of allowing mobile phone users to buy Treasury bonds through mobile money transfers. I wouldn’t bank your investments on this yet though, as the article was clear that “details are yet to be worked out” and this seems to be the sort of transaction where the devil is indeed in the details.
CGAP has announced exciting new opportunities for people interested in working in branchless banking as a way to reach the poor with financial services. We are looking for team players to help us advance global understanding on issues such as new and emerging business models, consumer insights, activation rates, regulation, agent networks, government payments and other areas in the increasingly complex branchless banking space.
See the job announcement here. The closing date for applications is November 30th.
One of many Brazilian agents that move people outside of bank branches
I’m blogging from Dakar, Senegal where I had a stark reminder of why innovation in financial services is so necessary. A colleague of mine had a check to cash, so after one of our meetings we made our way to a “to-remain-unnamed” bank in the city center. Good thing I decided not to wait in the car because this relatively simple transaction took well over an hour to complete. First we had to wait about 30 minutes for our number to be called behind all the people waiting ahead of us. But once he was at the teller, it still took my colleague about 45 minutes to finally walk away with his cash.
My intention is by no means to bash banks…the computer system seemed to be running slowly and the check was for a couple thousand dollars, so he was sent to another desk for some sort of extra authorization. But it was a good, and admittedly frustrating, reminder of the potential of branchless banking, technology and innovative business models to transform the way people, especially the unbanked, access financial services…outside of bank branches.
This experience aside, the Senegalese market is full of exciting initiatives and inspiring energy from banks, MFIs, mobile network operators, technology companies, various government institutions and the central bank. In perusing my Google feed of news on branchless and mobile banking, there are plenty of things around the world to get excited about. Here are just a few that caught my eye:
One of the banks that has a regional presence in the West African Economic and Monetary Union (WAEMU – of which Senegal is a part) is Morroccan-based Attijariwafa Bank. Wafacash, a specialized subsidiary of Attijariwafa and leader in international money transfers, announced the launch of a new mobile money transfer corridor in partnership with Belgacom subsidiary BICS between Belgium and Morocco.
A new study reports on the first randomized evaluation of a cash transfer program delivered via the mobile phone – Zain’s Zap service in Niger (now Airtel’s Airtel Money). The report highlights several benefits of this new delivery mechanism and we’ll be profiling this experience in more depth on our blog in the coming weeks.
Also related to cash transfers, a new report by UNCDF examines Fiji’s experience in leveraging government-to-person (G2P) payments as a mechanism to enhance financial inclusion and provide savings to government and social welfare recipients via a savings-linked electronic payment system.
In Bangladesh, the Bangladesh Bank has just published new guidelines on mobile financial services and the Financial Express reports that nearly a dozen banks are preparing to introduce such services, in addition to those services that are already in the market.
In Pakistan, the largest mobile network operator Mobilink, a subsidiary of Orascom Telecom, was recently granted a license by the State Bank of Pakistan to initiate microfinance activities, seen as their foray into branchless banking.
But I admit that what excited me the most when I looked through my Google feed was the fact that I read more than 20 headlines before finding a story that mentioned M-PESA. The rest of the world is catching up!
Summer is now officially over here in Washington and the busy fall season is off to a quick start. If you are just getting back into high gear, maybe this is a good time for us to recap some of the things we’ve been discussing on the blog over the last couple months, some of the latest news that’s caught our attention, and some things to keep your eye on in the coming weeks.
The South African bank FNB has recently launched its latest mobile banking offering Pay2Cell which allows FNB account holders to make payments to other FNB clients using only the recipient’s mobile phone number. This is a different product offering from FNB’s eWallet which allows FNB account holders to send money to anybody with a mobile phone. The recipient does not need a bank account and can withdraw the cash at any FNB ATM.
South Africa is one of the 7 markets that we covered in our recently released branchless banking country notes. The other countries include India, Pakistan, Mexico, Brazil, Ghana, and WAEMU in West Africa. The report for WAEMU is now also available in French – la version en français UEMOA.
An active branchless banking provider in West Africa, Orange has recently launched the Orange African Social Venture Prize. This initiative aims to reward innovative projects using ICT for social and economic development in Africa. In this contest, 3 winners will be selected and will receive financial grants along with 6-months of mentoring support from management and ICT experts. The project should target at least one country where Orange has a footprint and the prizes will be announced during the AfricaCom Awards in Cape Town in November. The deadline for applications is the end of September. Read more about it here.
Staying in West Africa, Nigeria continues to buzz with branchless banking activity. The Central Bank of Nigeria recently issued operating licenses to 11 mobile money firms. As this article explains:
Fiji G2P payments (courtesy of UNCDF's Pacific Financial Inclusion Programme)
Over the last couple months, we’ve run a series profiling different government payments programs that have innovated on their payment mechanisms and in some cases linked payments to financial services. We looked at the case of UBL in Pakistan making payments to flood victims. We profiled GCASH using GCASH REMIT to make payments on behalf of LandBank to rural beneficiaries of the 4Ps program in the Philippines. We featured Colombia’s Familias en Accion program that has contributed to the build out of banking correspondents in the country and is testing interesting ways to incentivize savings. We discussed the HSN Programme in Kenya and how Equity Bank is making payments to a very rural area in northern Kenya via smart cards and agents. Finally, we looked at the new G2P program in Fiji offering payments to beneficiaries through accounts offered by Westpac. Of course, we could have profiled many more schemes in countries like India, Mexico, South Africa, Dominican Republic, and others.
These examples are diverse as much as they are similar. Some of them are still in a pilot phase (such as GCCASH), while others are at a national scale (such as Familias en Accion). Some of them are using card-based solutions (such as the HSN Programme and Familias en Accion), while others are experimenting with mobile phones (such as GCASH). Some of them are distributing a payment based on certain conditionalities (such as the 4Ps program in the Philippines and Familias en Accion), while others are distributing unconditional cash transfers (such as in Fiji and the HSN Programme). What are some observations and lessons we can gather from these examples and from others around the world?
The link to financial inclusion is one that can often get forgotten in the quest for payment efficiency. Social protection programs rightly have the objective of making payments in a timely, efficient and cost-effective manner. While they often appreciate the link that financial services can offer to the beneficiaries, when push comes to shove, this will get sidelined if it becomes too complicated or costly to implement. Therefore we see that while the schemes in Pakistan and the Philippines have done an excellent job getting payments (and in Pakistan emergency payments no less) to poor beneficiaries, there is not yet a link to financial services. While this may be an added feature in the future, these examples should encourage all of us with a specific interest in financial inclusion to be deliberate and clear in our interaction with G2P partners about our real goals. Read the rest of this page »
