India, microfinance and technology: tackling efficiency from every angle

by Lauren Braniff : Sunday, June 20, 2010

Client meeting

Sahayata’s loan officers, or field credit officers (FCO), are able to spend the vast majority of their time working with clients rather than on data entry and other administrative tasks. Photo by Lauren Braniff

A typical day in the life of a microfinance loan officer might look something like this:

Arrive at the branch and print your agenda and reports for the day, which will typically include several group meetings at which you’ll disburse loans or collect payments, and perhaps hold meetings with prospective clients. After preparing for the day, you depart the office for a day in the field.

After spending the day traveling around to meet clients, you return to the branch and begin data entry. You enter the amount of money disbursed or collected from each client, and perhaps enter information on new clients or loan applications.

Between the morning and evening sessions at the branch, a typical loan officer might spend 25% or more of their time on data entry and other administrative tasks related to managing their portfolio.

What if you could reduce or even eliminate these tasks from the loan officer job description?

That’s exactly what one MFI in India, Sahayata, has done. Through an innovative operational model in which they strictly delineate tasks among staff, Sahayata’s loan officers, or field credit officers (FCO), are able to spend the vast majority of their time working with clients rather than on data entry and other administrative tasks.

At the center of Sahayata’s model is the central processing unit (CPU) in Jaipur where a team of about 14 data entry specialists receive scanned forms from the branches by email and duly enter the information in the MFI’s information system, BR.net by Craft Silicon. At the end of each day, they email a set of reports to each branch so the branch staff are prepared when they arrive the next morning.

Key to Sahayata’s efficient distribution of resources is both the specialization of roles and a salary structure to highly incentivize staff for performance. FCOs may make up to 100% of their base salary in incentives, which focus not only on the number of loans but also loan performance.  It’s great that the FCOs no longer have to spend time doing data entry, but the real result comes from the fact that they now use that time to market Sahayata to new clients. Under this new operating model, FCOs have increased their average case load from 300-350 clients per FCO to 600. In just 2.5 years of operations, Sahayata has grown to 175,000 clients.

Sahayata’s web-based portfolio management system also contributes to their efficient operating model. The first MFI to implement Craft Silicon’s new software as a service (SaaS) offering, BR.net, Sahayata pays a fee to access to the software over the internet. The servers and database are hosted by Craft Silicon so Sahayata did not need to make a large upfront investment in hardware, or in an IT team to manage the system. Instead, Sahayata’s IT experts are able to spend time on things like a mobile phone application for loan officers, to further enhance their efficiency when they’re away from the branch.

Back office management is a source of such stress for many MFIs that it’s exciting to see MFIs trying new and innovative ways of addressing these issues. Sahayata’s back office strategy includes not only technology, but also people and processes. This has been a recurring theme in a series of workshops organized by CGAP and Grameen Foundation over the past year and it’s clear that addressing all of these aspects – people, processes, and technology -  in a comprehensive manner is critical for an efficient and effective back office system.

-Lauren Braniff

Comments: Comments and trackbacks are open.

  • June 24th, 2010 at 2:25 pm, Fehmeen ()

    Efficiency, or the lack therefore, is a major problem for MFIs when their portfolios grow at break-neck speeds. Technology is an important tool, but here are two other methods used by MFIs (I read about them at the Kiva Blog):

    - extend the contract terms of certain borrowers to include three or four loan cycles (this reduces administrative costs associated with loan approval)

    - administer group loans to 50 or 60 people in one go, so all loans are disbursed in one go, and collections are made together, every two weeks, or every month (again, this reduces administrative and transport costs)

    These tools only work in certain conditions, but present a low-tech and low-cost option for improving efficiency.

  • June 26th, 2010 at 4:38 am, Oscar Ahere ()

    Imagine this…the Field Credit Officer trains the clients on how to send money to the MFI through their MMTS (Mobile money transfer service) and the core banking system at the head office is updated automatically. He can then get a printout of those who did NOT pay for follow up.

    Imagine if he could also register members and make loan applications from his handset. Imagine if the clients could get their loans directly to their phones..

    I think this would reduce the work of the Field loan Officer by 40% and leave him to do core business! This is POSSIBLE by using the all new RedCloud application!

  • July 7th, 2010 at 1:01 pm, Lauren Braniff ()

    Very exciting developments! Technology is really opening the path to many new ways of doing business. The opportunities are there, but bringing these technologies to life at MFIs presents many challenges (funding, capacity, strategy, vision, etc). Looking forward to seeing RedCloud in action!

  • December 13th, 2010 at 1:04 am, Arun ()

    There are much more simpler technologies for field collection, the Field Credit Officer carries just a mobile phone(ordinary)to the field. He can view his today visit group details with individual member wise loan status and can also enter loan dues collected in his mobile, which will be updated to server in few minutes.

    This totally removes data preparation and entry work both for Field officer and by a Data entry person. As still in India, the lower segment of people are not familiar with using mobile more than voice calls. (Basically we need to consider whether they have a mobile phone first)

    Field Officer can also register members and make loan applications from his handset.

    An individual or group who is knowledgeable to use mobile banking can go for mobile banking versions.

    mPowerForce WFA provides both the above services in SaaS model.

  • Leave a Reply